Archbishop Cruz and the “Public Sinner”

April 8th, 2008 by Julian Alejandro

Dagupan Archbishop Oscar Cruz recently said that public sinners should not be given the Holy communion. News reports said he was referring to Mrs. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo — the Philippines’ de facto president who is accused of election fraud and corruption. But the maverick archbishop denied he called Arroyo a public sinner who should not be given communion.

He told CBCPNews that all he stated was, according to the teachings of the Church, a public sinner should not be given communion.

He had earlier wrote on his blog:

“This is why as a matter of doctrinal principle and moral norm, someone known to the public as reasonably perceived or actually known guilty not simply of one, neither only three nor merely five but more grave or mortal sins of such as gross stealing, flagrant graft and corrupt practices, and other glaring big moral misdeeds with extensive and intensive adverse effects to society, fits the reality of a public sinner. To conclude otherwise, i.e., that the person concerned is holy or saintly, is not only irrational but also futile. And to give the Most Sacred Body and Blood of Christ to the same, is not simply highly offensive to the sensitivity of the simple Christian faithful in general but also—and primarily so—means a big contempt of inherent divinity and intrinsic sanctity of Christ Himself. That is why giving Holy Communion in public to a public sinner is a public scandal.

Romulo Macalintal, Arroyo’s election lawyer, said the archbishop’s statement was judgmental. He said a lay minister does not have the right to refuse the Holy Communion to anyone.

“Walang karapatan ang lay minister na tanggihan ang pagbibigay ng Holy Communion sa taong ‘yan. Kahit sa paningin ng isang pari o lay minister na ‘yan ay makasalanan, hindi niya problema ‘yan.Problema na noong kumukuha ng komunyon at ng kanyang Diyos,” Macalintal said in a GMA-7 report.

But Archbishop Cruz, a canon lawyer and former president of the Catholic Bishops’ of the Philippines, also wrote:

It is the responsibility and accountability of the Minister of Holy Communion to decide whom to give Holy Communion due to presumption of the worthiness of the recipient, and whom to deny it on account of sound conviction of unworthiness by reason of publicly known serious objective moral offenses—particularly those with wide and intensive adverse social impacts.

I think a canon lawyer, more than an election lawyer, would know the rules governing an issue of faith.

Meanwhile, Fr. Bel San Luis, in his column for the administration-friendly Manila Bulletin, wrote: “In Jesus’ parable of the self-righteous Pharisee and publican (public sinner), Archbishop Cruz, by his judgmental stance, would be the epitome of the Pharisee who condemned the poor publican.”

“But the Lord said: It was the tax collector, the self-accused sinner who “went down to his house justified rather than the other” (Lk 18:14).”

Fr. San Luis missed something. The tax collector, as he wrote, was a “self-accused sinner.” That is the reason the Lord defended him. But the public sinner Archbishop Cruz was probably referring to would rather lie than admit her sins against the people.

San Luis further wrote:

Archbishop Cruz should be more careful in judging “known” sinners. In the first place, how can he be sure they are sinners? Does he have a third eye to discern what’s inside the heart of a person? What if a particular sinner is trying hard to make peace with the Lord unknown to the prelate and others?

Duh?! Where you live, Father? In Enchanted Kingdom?

Tags: , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

want to buy Maxalt in malaysia buy cheap online pharmacy finpecia overnight shipping on generic orlistat achat orlistat xenical without script buy orlistat us overnight no prescription orlistat order xenical online with overnight delivery xenical on line no script xenical no doctors prescription (buy orlistat canada|generic Orlistat no prescription|Orlistat oral tablet no prescription discount|non prescription Orlistat|ordering Orlistat online without a precription|Orlistat online without a prescription) xenical with no prescription and delivered over night (to buy orlistat|Orlistat online cheap|online pharmacy Orlistat no prescription|were to buy Orlistat) (buy orlistat australia|buy Orlistat|buy Orlistat over the counter|canadian pharmacy no prescription Orlistat|no prescription Orlistat|order Orlistat no prescription|Orlistat no script|where can i buy Orlistat over the counter) (orlistat cheap no rx required canada|Orlistat purchase without perscripotion|buy generic Orlistat online|buy Orlistat pills no prescription|Orlistat precio|Orlistat without a prescription|generic Orlistat online|generic Orlistat without a precsriptions|Orlistat without prescriptions in usa|Xenical generic no prescription) (buy orlistat pills|buy Orlistat oral) (orlistat order overnight|buy Orlistat without a percsription|buy discounted Orlistat online|buy Orlistat india|buy Orlistat online without prescription from canada|canada Orlistat|canadian pharmacy Orlistat|generic Orlistat|I need to order Xenical without presciption and order it COD|Orlistat online cheap|order Orlistat online consultation|Orlistat buy no prescription|Orlistat online no prescription and overnight|Orlistat available at health department|Orlistat for sale without prescription|where can i buy Orlistat without a prescription?) xenical online uk where can i buy xenical without a prescription how to buy orlistat without a prescription order xenical online with overnight delivery can i get xenical without a prescription? buy xenical amex online order orlistat without rx from us pharmacy order xenical without a rx overnight shipping orlistat generic buy cheap orlistat no prescription uk orlistat cheap buy orlistat without prescription buy orlistat online without prescription xenical online sale without prescription xenical no script fedex order orlistat online overnight shipping buy cheap generic orlistat online order generic xenical online no prescription orlistat precio buy in orlistat uk order xenical for cash on delivery no prescription needed xenical orlistat u.p.s shipping cod buy cheap orlistat line i need to order xenical without a prescription buy orlistat australia overnight no prescription xenical orlistat on line generic orlistat no prescription keflex tablets buy principen amex online without prescription arcoxia pharmacy buy arcoxia no scams problems with buying casodex without rx buy cheap zovirax online prescription lamictal buy feldene shipped cod where to buy cheap zovirax no prescription desogen in canada buy atarax amex online without rx how to buy cleocin online without a prescription purchase cycrin pay pal online without prescription online pharmacies Atarax Online prescriptions Arcoxia Revia on line no prescription order atarax without a rx overnight shipping Revia cod online orders cheapest Feldene available online buy cheap generic Cleocin online Atarax order on line prescription Atarax online Generic Keflex online purchase Keflex without prescription from us pharmacy to buy Tenormin buy misoprostol cheap without perscription where can i buy some asacol online only using cash or money orders where to purchase cheap principen no rx buy benicar doctor prescription purchase keflex amex online without rx purchase zovirax over the counter cod overnight buy casodex uk tenormin tablets 100 mg no prescription australia buy cheap generic keflex tenormin online no prescription fedex comprar revia generico buy vantin diet pill tenormin order buy atarax on line amex vantin no physicisn consult want to buy atarax in malaysia cheapest tenormin available online vantin with no prescriptions keflex online consultation overnight where to buy generic keflex online without a prescription tenormin without prescriptions in usa atarax overnight us delivery zovirax with no prescription overnight shipping revia no prescription needed 50mg uk medication orlistat xenical buy online purchase orlistat usa cod buy xenical online without a script how to order asacol fedex arcoxia overnight without a prescription arcoxia without prescription shipped overnight express buy arcoxia online cycrin mexico vantin uk sales where to buy vantin by cod buy keflex 500 mg purchase casodex over the counter cod overnight order cleocin online no membership overnight shipping atarax 100 mg casodex in canada non rx cheap casodex next day fedex shipping for atarax buy misoprostol cheap without perscription where to buy generic orlistat online without a rx buy in orlistat uk order xenical no prescription buy xenical no prescription needed buy orlistat next day delivery buy xenical online without prescription uk medication xenical orlistat buy online medikament orlistat xenical without a prescription buy xenical online overnight xenical 60 mg without prescription xenical no physician order xenical no prescription online prescription Maxalt buy discount Maxalt line buy low cost Maxalt buy cheapest Maxalt buy Maxalt from india buy Maxalt on line amex buy no online rx Rizatriptan buy discount Maxalt line buy Maxalt with no prescription online Maxalt buy generic xenical fedex cheap orlistat uk orlistat online without a prescription buy generic orlistat canada buy xenical no prescription orlistat for sale canadian prescriptions xenical purchase orlistat without rx needed orlistat buy online in stock buy xenical next day delivery orlistat in usa where to buy requip online Premarin uk buy requip uk buy requip buy no prescription generic Premarin no prescription generic of requip requip 1 mg purchase buy generic orlistat canada purchase orlistat overnight purchase orlistat cod next day delivery orlistat available canada i need to order orlistat without a prescription order prescription free xenical requip canada pharmacy requip 1 mg purchase requip generic order requip overnight requip online india requip online india cost of requip australia requip prescription assistance buy requip australia arimidex purchase overnight delivery order arimidex overnight arimidex no prescription needed getting arimidex without doctor buy cheap generic arimidex online canada pharmacy no prescription cheap arimidex no prescription needed feldene desogen online next day shipping vantin with out a prescription buy arcoxia doctor prescription tenormin and tenormin order asacol pay cleocin casodex from mexico fedex keflex without priscription purchase asacol online no membership overnight shipping revia non prescription for next day delivery tenormin overnight without prescription purchase benicar without prescription needed revia 50mg buy vantin online 200 mg no prescription cytotec order overnight buy orlistat line overnight xenical without a prescription cheap xenical without a prescription order cheap overnight orlistat best orlistat online pill xenical online no rx overnight online orlistat order order arimidex online overnight shipping buy Arimidex 1 mg buy Arimidex now buy Arimidex visa where can i get Arimidex Arimidex order overnight Arimidex purchase without prescription Arimidex buy no prescription Arimidex mastercard Rizatriptan Maxalt buy cheap generic Maxalt online buy Maxalt online pills best buy Maxalt cheapest place to buy Maxalt buy Maxalt online us pharmacy buy cheap Maxalt no prescription buy cheap generic Maxalt online buy cheap generic maxalt online buy next day Maxalt where can i buy Maxalt without prescription 10 mg Maxalt non rx cheap Maxalt maxalt sale order no prescription Maxalt Maxalt no prescription overnight Maxalt capsule Maxalt uk buy Maxalt discount buy Maxalt epharmacist Maxalt canada order generic Maxalt buy discount Maxalt line order generic Maxalt Maxalt generic maxalt fedex shipping where to buy Maxalt online generic Maxalt prices Maxalt usa buy Maxalt no prescription low cost where can i buy herbal Maxalt buy Maxalt us cheapest place to buy revia buy revia no visa without rx revia online next day shipping uk order revia buy revia without a perscription non presciption revia buy revia online consultation us buy next day asacol buy cheap asacol without a prescription purchasing vantin online without prescription buy cheap generic arcoxia atarax online with next day shipping buy Lisinopril free consultation generic Lisinopril cost buy Keflex once a day buying Premarin Metformin rezept buy Metformin online without prescription non prescription Cytotec buy Cytotec for women how to buy casodex on line purchase online rx zovirax without purchase cleocin online without prescription canadian pharmacy no prescription asacol Canadian Revia Metformin online buy Alli in united states online where can i purchase metformin online prednisone online no prescription overnight where can i buy orlistat without a perscription? mail order xenical xenical overnight no consult fedex xenical overnight without a prescription xenical without prescription buy online rx xenical without buy xenical without prescription how to get orlistat online no prescription in 120 days buy cheap generic xenical buy orlistat no prescriptions buy orlistat line xenical order overnight buy xenical without prescription to ship overnight buy cod orlistat buy xenical online without a prescription and no membership buying xenical online xenical without a prescription or membership purchase online rx orlistat without no prescription xenical on line pharmacy orlistat 120 mg pharmacy where you can purchas� orlistat without prescription